Submitting an Effective Death Benefit Appeal

Fighting for the Life Insurance Benefits You Deserve

“Brent Brehm is not just an excellent attorney but a fine human being. I have been a fortunate beneficiary of his brilliance, comprehensiveness and candor, all of which he glued together with his integrity and compassion....At very short notice, he looked at complex documentation, offered actionable advice and warned about buried landmines. That guidance, once again, helped give me a stronger hand in financial negotiations. Also, he doesn’t just advise on “what should I do?” He takes a holistic view of the situation so as to customize his advice and empower his clients. He treats them with respect, not as helpless bystanders....In those moments of despair, Brent offers a calm competence. In this day and age, that is a priceless gift. I recommend him in the most emphatic terms....”
— Posted by Nishant

Facing a denied life insurance or AD&D claim?

Don't lose hope. At Dorian Law, we understand the profound emotional and financial hardship a denial creates. We are here to guide you through the appeal process and fight for the benefits you deserve. Please know that a denial is not always the final word. You have the right to appeal, and submitting a strong, effective appeal is crucial to securing the benefits you or your family is entitled to. Our Client-Focused Approach means we are dedicated to supporting you through this challenging process with empathy and understanding.

It's natural to feel discouraged after a claim denial. You might even be tempted to give up. However, appealing is often a necessary and worthwhile step. Insurance companies, like any business, sometimes make errors, misinterpret policy language, or even act in bad faith.

This page is dedicated to guiding you through the process of appealing a denied life insurance or AD&D death claim. We will explain why appeals are important, what steps to take, and how Dorian Law, with its combination of Deep Industry Knowledge, Proven Track Record of Success, and Our Client-Focused Approach, can significantly increase your chances of overturning a wrongful denial.

Hire Dorian Law for Your Life Insurance Appeal

Here are five reasons why:

  • We don't take a one-size-fits-all approach. We meticulously analyze your specific denial, gather all necessary documentation, and craft a compelling legal argument tailored to your situation to maximize your chances of a successful appeal.

  • Our attorneys possess a thorough understanding of life insurance policies, the reasons for denials, and the specific requirements for successful appeals. We leverage this deep knowledge to build the strongest possible case for your appeal.

  • The attorneys at Dorian Law have a history of successfully challenging life insurance and AD&D claim denials and securing the benefits our clients are rightfully owed. Our experience speaks for itself when it comes to navigating the complexities of these cases.

  • We understand that dealing with a denied life insurance claim after the loss of a loved one is incredibly stressful. We provide empathetic support, clear communication, and a guiding hand throughout the entire appeal process.

  • Let us handle the sometimes complex paperwork, navigate the often-frustrating communication with the insurance company, and advocate on your behalf, allowing you to focus on what matters most during this challenging time.

A well-prepared appeal gives you the opportunity to:

  • Correct Errors: Point out mistakes in the insurance company's investigation or interpretation of the policy.

  • Provide Missing Information: Submit additional documentation or evidence that supports your claim and addresses the reasons for denial.

  • Strengthen Your Case: Present compelling legal arguments and policy interpretations that demonstrate why the claim should be paid. This is where Our Deep Industry Knowledge of policy language and legal precedent becomes invaluable.

  • Preserve Your Rights: For ERISA-governed policies, exhausting the administrative appeal process is mandatory before you can pursue legal action in court. For individual policies, a strong appeal can sometimes resolve the issue without the need for litigation, or significantly strengthen your position if litigation becomes necessary. Our Proven Track Record includes successfully resolving claims at the appeal stage, saving clients time and stress.

General Elements of an Effective Life Insurance or AD&D Appeal

Regardless of whether your policy is ERISA-governed or individual, certain principles are key to crafting a persuasive appeal:

  • Be Thorough and Meticulous: A rushed or incomplete appeal undermines your chances of success. Invest the time to gather all relevant information, construct a well-reasoned argument, and present a professional appeal package.

  • Focus on the Facts and the Policy Language: Ground your appeal in the specific facts of the case and the exact wording of the life insurance policy. Avoid emotional appeals and focus on logical, evidence-based arguments.

  • Be Organized and Clear: Structure your appeal letter logically. Use clear headings and bullet points to make it easy for the insurer to follow your arguments and review your evidence.

  • Keep Copies of Everything: Maintain copies of your appeal letter, all supporting documents, and all correspondence with the insurance company.

  • Document Everything: Keep detailed records of all communication with the insurer, including dates, times, names of representatives, and summaries of conversations.

Understand the Reason for Denial

The first and most critical step in preparing an appeal is to carefully review the denial letter you received from the insurance company. This letter must explain the specific reasons for the denial. Common reasons include:

  • Alleged Material Misrepresentation on the Application

  • Policy Exclusion Applied

  • Policy Lapsed for Non-Payment of Premiums

  • Dispute over Cause of Death (especially in AD&D claims)

  • Contestability Period Issues

Once you understand the stated reason for denial, you can begin to build your appeal to directly address those issues. If you are not sure why your claim was denied, let us know and we’ll work with you to figure that our for free. At Dorian Law, we know that sometimes the stated reason for denial is not the real reason for denial and digging deeper is necessary.

Is Your Policy Governed by ERISA or State Law?

This Matters for Your Appeal Process

ERISA-Governed Policies (Group Policies through employers)

ERISA dictates a very specific administrative appeal process. You must exhaust this internal appeal process within the insurance company before you can file a lawsuit in federal court. ERISA appeals are typically decided based on the "administrative record" – the information presented during the appeal. It’s harder to introduce new evidence later in court. Because ERISA appeals have strict deadlines and procedural requirements, give strong consideration to obtaining experienced legal counsel.

Individual Policies (Purchased Directly or via non-employer groups)

Appeals for individual policies are generally governed by state law. The process is less rigidly defined than ERISA. While there may not be a mandatory "administrative appeal" in the ERISA sense, you can still submit a formal appeal or request for reconsideration to the insurance company before initiating legal action. This can be a valuable step in attempting to resolve the issue without litigation and building a strong record.

Submitting an Effective ERISA Life Insurance Appeal

If your life insurance policy is governed by ERISA (likely if it was through an employer), here’s what you need to know to submit an effective ERISA appeal:

  • Deadlines are Crucial: ERISA sets strict deadlines for filing your initial appeal. Missing these deadlines can be fatal to your claim. Act promptly! The denial letter must state the appeal deadline, usually 60 days from the date of denial and sometimes 180 days.

  • Focus on Building a Strong Administrative Record: Under ERISA, the court's review of a claim denial is generally limited to the "administrative record." This means your appeal is your primary opportunity to present all evidence and arguments supporting your claim. Gather everything upfront and submit it to the insurance company. If needed, ask for extensions of the appeal deadline so that you can build the strongest appeal possible. If you feel you might not be up to do the meticulous preparation needed to develop a strong administrative record, seek the help of experienced legal counsel.

  • Demand All Plan Documents and Relevant Information: Formally request, in writing, all plan documents from the plan administrator (usually the employer). Do the same for the insurance company, but ask for the claim file, procedures, and any internal rules, guidelines, or protocols the insurer had available in evaluating your claim. ERISA requires them to provide these. Doing this ensures you know exactly why your claim was denied. Experienced counsel will know how to use this information to your advantage.

  • “Full and Fair Review”: ERISA requires insurance companies to conduct a "full and fair review" of your appeal. This means they must consider all evidence you submit, provide you with access to relevant documents and information used in making their decision, ensure the appeal decision is made by someone independent of the initial denial, and explain the reasons for their decision in detail, referencing policy terms and evidence. It also means the appeal is not an adversarial process. Use this to your advantage - ask the insurance company to tell you exactly what they need to perfect your claim.

What to Include in Your ERISA Appeal

A successful ERISA appeal must be comprehensive and meticulously prepared. It should include:

  • A Detailed Appeal Letter: Clearly state that you are appealing the denial. Identify the policy number, claimant name, and date of denial. State you are requesting a "full and fair review" under ERISA. Our Client-Focused Approach involves crafting clear and persuasive appeal letters on your behalf.

  • Thoroughly Rebut the Denial Reasons: Address each reason given for the denial in the insurance company’s letter, point by point. Explain why their rationale is incorrect or unsupported by the facts or policy language. Our Deep Industry Knowledge allows us to dissect denial letters and identify weaknesses in the insurer's arguments.

  • Present All Relevant Evidence: Gather and submit all documentation that supports your claim and counters the denial reasons. Our Proven Track Record is built on thorough evidence gathering and presentation. This might include:

    • Medical Records: If the denial relates to a medical condition or cause of death, provide complete and relevant medical records, physician statements, and expert opinions.

    • Witness Statements: Statements from family members, friends, or colleagues who can provide relevant information about the deceased's health, lifestyle, or circumstances surrounding the death.

    • Policy Documents: Re-submit the policy itself to ensure it is in the record. Highlight specific policy language that supports your claim and contradicts the insurer's interpretation.

    • Legal Arguments and Policy Interpretation: If the denial involves a policy interpretation issue or exclusion, present legal arguments and case law supporting your interpretation of the policy language.

    • Expert Opinions (Medical or Vocational): If appropriate, obtain expert opinions from physicians or other professionals to support your claim, particularly if the denial is medically based or related to AD&D “accident” definitions.

  • Maintain Professional Communication: While it’s understandable to be frustrated, maintain a professional and respectful tone in your appeal letter and all communications with the insurance company. Focus on facts, evidence, and legal arguments. Our Client-Focused Approach includes managing all communications with the insurer professionally and strategically, relieving you of this burden.

Submitting an Appeal for an Individual Life Insurance or AD&D Policy

For policies not governed by ERISA (typically individual policies), the appeal process is less strictly regulated, and sometimes not required at all. However, there are times when an appeal is still vital.

  • Review Your Policy and State Insurance Laws: Check your policy for any stated appeal procedures. Also, research your state's insurance laws, which may provide some guidance or consumer protection regulations regarding claim denials and appeals.

  • Submit a Formal Appeal or Request for Reconsideration: Even if not explicitly required, submitting a formal written appeal to the insurance company is generally advisable. Treat this appeal seriously and prepare it as thoroughly as possible.

  • Elements of an Effective Appeal (Similar to ERISA, but with more flexibility): While the focus on the "administrative record" is less rigid than ERISA, the key elements of a strong appeal are similar. Clearly state you are appealing the denial, referencing the policy provisions and facts that drive a positive outcome.

  • Address Denial Reasons: Directly refute each reason for denial outlined in their letter.

  • Present Supporting Evidence: Gather and submit any new or existing evidence that strengthens your claim, including medical records, witness statements, and policy documentation. While very important, if the matter proceeds to litigation, additional information can be obtained and used.

  • Strong Arguments: Present clear and logical arguments based on policy language, facts, and applicable state law.

  • Consider Legal Arguments and State Law: While not always necessary at this stage, if the denial involves complex legal or policy interpretation issues, consider incorporating legal arguments based on state contract law or insurance regulations.

  • Timeline: Insurers for individual policies may have internal timelines for appeals, but these are usually less strict than ERISA deadlines. However, it's still best to act promptly and follow up if you don't receive a response within a reasonable timeframe (e.g., 30-60 days). Our Proven Track Record includes efficiently managing appeal timelines and proactively following up with insurers.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) About Appealing Denied Life Insurance and AD&D Claims

  • A: We often work on a contingency fee basis for life insurance and AD&D appeal cases. This reflects Our Client-Focused Approach, ensuring you have access to experienced legal representation without upfront financial burden. We also work on an hourly basis. Whichever option suits you, hiring an attorney for your appeal may save you money in the long run by avoiding litigation or maximizing you recovery in litigation.

  • A: For ERISA-governed policies, the deadline is typically 60 days from the date of the denial letter. Sometimes it is as long as 180 days. For individual policies, timelines vary. Our Client-Focused Approach ensures we immediately clarify all deadlines in your specific case and keep you informed. Delay can weaken your position.

  • A: Yes, and you should! Your appeal is the opportunity to strengthen your case. An effective appeal includes gathering strategic evidence and presentation. For ERISA appeals, this is particularly critical as this is likely your last opportunity to present evidence.

  • A: The insurance company will review your appeal. They may ask for additional information. If they do, provide it promptly. Once all information is submitted, timelines vary, but we recommend being proactive with following-up to ensure timely processing and response.

  • A: If your appeal is denied, you have further legal options. For ERISA denials, you can file in federal court; for individual policies, in state court or, in some instances, federal court. We strongly recommend you hire an attorney if you want to sue the insurance company.

  • A: In ERISA cases, the administrative record is crucial. It contains all the information provided to, obtained by, or available to the insurance company in making the decision on your claim. Knowing how to build a strong administrative record that maximizes your chances of success, both in the appeal and, if necessary, in court, is often the difference between getting a claim paid and getting nothing.

  • While you can submit an appeal on your own, at least consider seeking experienced legal counsel. We have seen excellent appeals done by individuals. Unfortunately, we have seen far more appeals that were ineffective or harmful. Experienced legal counsel can significantly increase your chances of a successful outcome by building the strongest possible appeal on your behalf.

Don't let a wrongful denial deter you. Let Dorian Law champion your appeal. Contact us for a free consultation to discuss your denied claim and learn how we can help you submit a powerful and effective appeal.